The perception: AI has broken the assessment model
A university's core promise is that its graduates have mastered the discipline knowledge and skills indicated by their graduation certificate. However, since the explosion of generative AI in late 2022, students are producing passing-quality assignments, essays, and even exam answers using tools like ChatGPT, Claude and many others. The result: degrees that no longer guarantee competence.
“The offloading of challenging tasks to AI tools, such as summarising reading materials, conducting research, solving problems, drafting text, or writing in English when it is not a student’s first language, can weaken learning by circumventing the productive struggle needed to develop knowledge and skills.” Office for Students, UK
96% fell to 49%: The 96% average on a take home exam fell to 49% when the students had to redo it in-class (Brown University, Inside Higher Ed). 94%: of full-time undergraduate students in the UK say they use generative AI to help with assessed work (HEPI Student Generative AI Survey 2026). 90%+: rate of cheating reported by students themselves in their courses (Student reports, The Australian, Feb 2026).
96% fell to 49%: The 96% average on a take home exam fell to 49% when the students had to redo it in-class
94%: of full-time undergraduate students in the UK say they use generative AI to help with assessed work
90%+: rate of cheating reported by students themselves in their courses
"Cheating has become omnipresent. I don't know a single person who hasn't used A.I. to get through some assignment in college."
"The only way to eliminate AI cheating is to go back to in-person supervised exams, in-class presentations, oral assessments, practical lab assignments and defending of essays."
The challenge is real, the conversation is growing
Leading academics, and education experts are calling for urgent reform. Here is what they are saying.
Brown professor suspects most of his class used AI to cheat
For the first time since he started teaching Welfare Economics and Social Choice Theory nearly two decades ago, Brown University economics professor Roberto Serrano gave his students a take-home midterm this spring. When the midterm came along, the average score was 96 percent. With the blessing of his dean, Professor Serrano changed the final exam to an in-person test. Three students earned a zero, and the average score on the final was 48.6 percent—by far a historic low, he said.
Inside Higher Ed
I’m an academic, but I’ve told my stepdaughter to think twice about going to university
Industrial-scale fraud is undermining the value of tertiary qualifications. As an academic, I have seen first-hand how Al-enabled cheating has spread, and it has made me question whether a university degree still holds the value it once did.
Kylie Moore-Gilbert
What A.I. did to my college class
Cheating has become omnipresent. I don’t know a single person who hasn’t used A.I. to get through some assignment in college, yet the school was at first slow to realize how widespread this would become. As freshman year went on, some professors suggested that the “nuclear option” might be called for: allowing faculty to proctor in-person exams, a practice banned at the university for over a century to demonstrate “confidence in the honor” of students.
Theo Baker
Rampant AI cheating is ruining education alarmingly fast
Nearly 90 percent of college students had used ChatGPT to help with homework. Massive numbers of students are going to emerge from university with degrees, and into the workforce, who are essentially illiterate. We're talking about an entire generation of learning perhaps significantly undermined here.
James D. Walsh